Wondering where to go for the best deals when it comes to school supplies? My answer is this: it solely depends on how much time you have, how much money you want to save, and how many times you want to go.
I went to three different stores (Staples, Target and Walmart) with one basic sixth-grade school supply list. I thought, “Gee, this will be easy. Just write down the prices and you’re done.” What I found to be true was this: If you need two of something, you will most likely have to buy three or more; no store carries the exact same quantities or brands; and if you try to make a list of costs for three stores on the same item, you will lose your mind.
Quite frankly, I did the best I could. I tried to compare store brands, when possible, and I tried to compare the most alike items I could find. And to complicate things further, Staples apparently holds regular Penny Deals, but not on everything at once, not to mention the specials that Target and Walmart will most likely showcase as the new school year draws near. But here is what I found during one random day of power shopping. You be the judge:
(Price list here – to be sent to Molly in Excel spreadsheet)
Final Thoughts:
Staples: It was difficult to find everything in different sections of the store, and overall the prices were higher. However, if you are willing to watch weekly ads and take advantage of their ongoing sales, which can include penny and dollar items, then you will save significantly more than what is listed above. Multiple trips will probably be needed in order to take advantage of all sales.
Bottom line: Staples is a good destination for die-hard shoppers who watch for and take advantage of discounts, or for those who need larger quantities. Perfect for teachers and large families.
Target: Items were easily found, all in one area of the store, with enough room to mingle without feeling congested. While some items were priced slightly higher than Walmart, the selection was a bit more varied. I was able to find everything on the list, however, the zippered binders were in short supply. The color and design choices for items like pencil pouches, folders, notebooks and other random supplies were extensive.
Bottom line: If style and design choices are important, Target is a perfect option.
Walmart: The back-to-school section here was located right by a main entrance and easily accessible, however, the aisles were a bit on the congested side. All items on the list were in stock except for the zippered binder. Overall, the lowest prices were here, and this, along with the ability to get in and get out quickly, made the shopping experience fairly painless.
Bottom line: For thrifty, no-nonsense shoppers, Walmart is a good bet.
